Creator: Patrick Connole
Argentum-NIC: Record Sr. Housing Demand, but Not Development

Argentum and NIC MAP explain why record demand for senior housing has not resulted in more development.
Argentum and NIC MAP have a new report out to answer a fundamental question hovering over the senior housing sector, which is why with record demand for such housing is there not a corresponding amount of record development?
Titled, “Half the Ledger - Why Record Demand Hasn't Produced Record Development,” the findings offer reasons to answer the question.
“Senior housing has spent the last four years telling a demand story, and it holds up,” the report said. “Occupancy has climbed back above its pre-2020 level on every measure NIC MAP tracks, absorption has run at record levels, and the population that needs this housing is growing faster than the inventory built to serve it.”
On the demand side, the evidence is strong and consistent. But developers don't underwrite occupancy, the report said.
“They underwrite net operating income [NOI], and that half of the ledger tells a less finished story. Revenue per unit has climbed back above trend and kept rising. NOI per unit moved above its pre-2020 baseline for the first time in 2025. Margin, NOI as a share of revenue, has not moved above that baseline,” the report said.
That gap, the authors said, between a strong top line and a lagging bottom line is where the report spends most of its time, “because it's also where the answer to a two-thirds drop in construction starts since 2021 lives, and because closing it, not closing the demand case further, is what ultimately decides whether new supply follows.”
Key Findings
- The demand case is strong. The construction case is not. Occupancy, absorption, and population growth all point in the same direction.
- Construction starts have fallen every year since 2021, from more than 30,000 units annually to 10,000 in 2025, a divergence that demand-side data cannot explain, and one that has now persisted long enough that it no longer reads as a temporary pause.
- NOI per unit is finally growing faster than the baseline it's measured against, but margin isn't. In 2025, NOI per unit moved above its pre-2020 baseline for the first time (+$1,812), after four years below it. Margin, meanwhile, remains 6.6 points below where it stood before 2020, down from a 19.8-point gap at the 2022 trough, but not closed. On a typical property's revenue base that remaining 6.6 points is worth $3,800 in NOI per unit still left on the table.
- The median describes very few actual properties. NOI margins span roughly 6 percent at the 10th percentile to 49 percent at the 90th. Segment-level analysis shows most of what looks like a size or regional pattern in the pooled data is a property-type mix effect.
- Labor is the largest single piece of the gap, and it hasn't moved the same way in every property type. Labor cost, measured as a share of revenue (not of total operating expense), has climbed from 39 percent to 48 percent in assisted living since 2015, but peaked in 2021 and has since eased back nearly three points. In independent living, labor has risen from 20 percent to 29 percent of revenue over the same period and has not peaked.
- Since 2022, assisted living's labor share has eased every year while independent living's has risen every year. That divergence survives a direct check against occupancy: assisted living's labor share rose from 38.7 percent to 48.4 percent of revenue between 2015 and 2025 while occupancy for that comparison sat at essentially the same level in both years (88.1 percent vs. 88.0 percent), and independent living's rose from 23.4 percent to 28.9 percent across a similarly occupancy matched window (90.3 percent vs. 90.8 percent).
- In both segments the rise holds at matched occupancy, so occupancy alone doesn’t explain it. Rising resident acuity, which raises both care costs and care revenue, may account for part of it, particularly in assisted living.
Go to www.argentum.org to access the full report.
Comments or questions? Contact Patrick Connole at pconnole@parkplacelive.com.

