Creator: Patrick Connole

News Now|Operations|Compliance|Regulatory

CMS Fraud Rule CRUSH Draws a Measure of ‘Bronx Cheer’

Freestyle3 min readNov 17, 2026
Article thumbnail

Not everyone was thrilled with the new CMS proposal to further go after fraud, waste, and abuse.

CMS has issued a proposed rule called “Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare (CRUSH)” that seeks changes to enhance provider screening and enrollment safeguards, requirements for prompt self-reporting and return of identified FFS overpayments, and better managed-care program-integrity reporting, among other items.


In a word, it covers a lot. And, while the nursing home sector welcomed the proposal, it came with a cautionary tone, and indeed one former industry leader dismissed the effort.


“This [the draft rule] reads like a Truth Social post and not a CMS Fact Sheet for a proposed rule. There may be measurable or maybe no savings in the long list of items claiming potential savings that COULD be obtained in a CMS organization that has been ravaged by cost savings and personnel cuts,” said Martin Allen, the former senior vice president of reimbursement policy for AHCA/NCAL.


“Who the hell is going to do all this work? Hopefully, not the failed outside contractor programs that have produced erroneous audit findings thankfully overturned on provide appeal,” he added.


Brian Fuller, managing director, value-based care design and delivery, ATI Advisory, said the proposal continues to expand the scrutiny, authority, and accountability of fraud, waste, and abuse (FWA) across Medicare and Medicaid.


“Some of the provisions are new [such as the ability to revoke providers from the Medicare program] and some are not new [extrapolating Medicare Advantage audit findings on a small sample across their entire enrollment]. This builds on the RFI from earlier this year and further illustrates the commitment to identify FWA and remove it from government healthcare programs,” he said. 


The effort also continues a relentless focus by the Dept. of Health and Human Services and CMS on FWA topic. Indeed, with the announcement of the draft CRUSH rule, CMS said when implemented the rule could save taxpayers nearly $90 billion over the next 10 years across Medicare, Medicaid, the Children's Health Insurance Program, and the Health Insurance Marketplace.


What’s Important for SNFs in the Proposal?

John Kane, senior vice president of reimbursement policy, AHCA/NCAL, said the association supports CMS’s efforts to prevent fraud and protect the Medicare and Medicaid dollars that residents count on for care. “We appreciate that the proposal reflects some of the recommendations we shared with CMS earlier this year,” he added. 


Kane said that while CMS considers changes to how providers report information and receive payment, the association urges the agency to focus on areas where the risk of fraud is greatest.


“Providers acting in good faith need a timely way to correct unintended errors and resolve payment issues so seniors’ access to care is not disrupted or compromised. We look forward to submitting comments and will continue to advocate that CMS find the proper balance of accountability while still supporting care continuity,” he said. 


In a blog post on CRUSH, AHCA/NCAL presented a brief summary of the major provisions of the proposed rule impacting providers. These include: 


Provider Enrollment: CMS would shorten the deadline for routine Medicare enrollment updates from 90 days to 30 days. It would also allow CMS to deny or revoke a provider’s enrollment during a change in majority ownership based on another party’s failure to meet enrollment requirements, the post said.


“A buyer that reports a sale on time could still see its ability to receive Medicare payments jeopardized by a seller’s mistake. We will continue to urge CMS to preserve reasonable reporting deadlines, give providers acting in good faith an opportunity to correct unintended errors, and tie enforcement decisions to the conduct of the party involved,” AHCA/NCAL said. 


Medicare Advantage: Beginning Jan. 1, 2030, eligible providers would need approved Original Medicare enrollment to receive MA payment, including for out-of-network care. In addition, CMS is proposing to require MA and Part D plans to report cases of substantiated or suspected provider fraud, waste, and abuse. CMS also proposes using sampled audit findings to calculate risk-adjustment overpayments across an entire plan contract, starting with payment year 2018. 


Medicaid: States could rely on a federal agency’s finding that a fraud allegation is credible to suspend payments. If law enforcement declines the referral, a state could continue the hold during an active investigation, with written review at least quarterly. CMS also proposes a six-year lookback for self-identified Medicaid FFS overpayments. Providers would have to report and return the money by either 60 days after identification of the overpayment or the due date of an applicable cost report, whichever is later, the post said. 


AHCA/NCAL said it will be submitting comments to the proposal, which are due Jan. 19. 


The proposed rule is available in the Federal Register at https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2026-23461.pdf 


View the proposed rule fact sheet at https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/comprehensive-regulations-uncover-suspicious-healthcare-crush-proposed-rule-cms-6098-p.


Read the AHCA/NCAL blog at CMS Issues CRUSH Proposed Rule.


Comments or questions? Contact Patrick Connole at pconnole@parkplacelive.com.