Creator: Patrick Connole

News Now|Quality|Other|Regulatory

Sprawling CMS Proposal Creates New Type of MA Market

Freestyle5 min readNov 20, 2026
Article thumbnail

CMS issued a proposed rule late on Nov. 20 that would create a new type of MA market, including a new CMMI model.

CMS wants to create a new type of Medicare Advantage (MA) and Part D marketplace that rewards better care and better value and gives beneficiaries plan options that are lacking currently. Among a host of changes included in the proposed rule is the establishment of a first-of-its-kind mandatory, 10-year, Aligning Data and Value to Nurture Competition and Efficiency in Medicare Advantage (ADVaNCE MA) model launching in 2029 in select states. 


The proposed rule came out late on Nov. 20. You can view it on the Federal Register at https://www.federalregister.gov/d/2026-23960. The title is “Contract Year 2028 Policy and Technical Changes to the Medicare Advantage Program, Medicare Prescription Drug Benefit Program, and Medicare Cost Plan Program (CMS-4214-P2).”


If finalized, CMS said the proposed policy updates, alongside the new CMS Innovation Center (CMMI) model (ADVaNCE MA), “would break down administrative barriers for new market entrants, elevate prevention through nutrition to improve MA seniors’ health outcomes, and pioneer localized care innovations.”


To understand the proposal, here is the breakdown provided by CMS. 


Advancing MAHA Principles Through Healthier Food Benefits

The proposed rule would establish a consistent “healthy food" standard for MA supplemental benefits. Food and beverage supplemental benefits — including the Food and Produce Special Supplemental Benefits for the Chronically Ill benefit, used nearly 40 million times by chronically ill enrollees in 2025 — would need to consist of whole, nutrient-dense foods that align with the 2025–2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans.


CMS said items that don't meet this standard, like certain high-caloric oral nutritional supplements, could still be covered if specifically recommended by a healthcare provider to meet an enrollee's medical needs.


Streamlining Network Adequacy and the MA Application Review 

To expand MA options, CMS is proposing updates to the MA application and network adequacy requirements. CMS would require organizations to demonstrate network adequacy compliance during their first operational year, rather than during the application process. This update would remove a substantial barrier to market entry, allowing for increased competition and access to more plan choices for beneficiaries. If finalized, the rule would also reduce application appeals and bid delays while reflecting the actual, dynamic conditions under which care is delivered, CMS said.


CMS is also proposing to combine three separate behavioral health specialty types (clinical psychology, clinical social work, and outpatient behavioral health) into a single unified specialty type for purposes of network adequacy.

MA plans would have the flexibility to build more robust behavioral health networks that ensure beneficiaries have adequate access to these critical services, while addressing provider shortages and reducing disproportionate negotiating leverage that can inflate healthcare costs. Additionally, CMS is proposing to expand the telehealth credit within the current network adequacy framework. 


Strengthening and Simplifying Star Ratings

CMS is proposing changes to simplify and refocus the Star Ratings measure set, building on the recent changes finalized in the Contract Year 2027 final rule (91 FR 17384).


The proposed measure set of 15 measures reflects the agency’s ongoing effort to sharpen the Star Ratings program's focus on clinical outcomes while continuing to encourage high performance on patient experience. The measure set would also include a small number of process measures in areas of high clinical importance where contracts’ current performance is low. The measure removals would apply (that is, data will be collected and performance measured) for the 2028 measurement period and the 2030 Star Ratings. 


Consistent with the intent of the Contract Year 2027 final rule, CMS also proposed removing the reward factor and modifying the hold harmless methodology for the improvement measures to apply only to contracts receiving 4.5 or higher stars for their highest rating.


These changes to the measure set and methodology would streamline and simplify the Star Ratings while also raising the bar to achieve high Star Ratings and associated Quality Bonus Payments (QBPs) to incentivize plans to improve performance and ensure the highest quality of care for their enrollees.


CMS is also proposing a change to the methodology for setting cut points to account for the potential impact of the ADVaNCE MA model and several other technical and policy clarifications.


Improvements for Special Needs Plans

CMS is proposing changes to promote care coordination among certain MA special needs plans (SNPs) with high proportions of dually eligible individuals and changes to introduce additional choice and competition into markets with integrated MA dual eligible special needs plans (D-SNPs).


Specifically, CMS is proposing to:


  • Require chronic condition special needs plans (C-SNPs) and certain institutional special needs plans (I-SNPs) with 60 percent or more dually eligible individuals to coordinate with Medicaid across health care settings, providers, and services for full-benefit dually eligible individuals (for C-SNPs and institutional-equivalent special needs plans (IE-SNPs), this applies to all full-benefit dually eligible enrollees; for hybrid institutional special needs plans (HI-SNPs), this applies to full-benefit dually eligible enrollees who reside in the community). Dually eligible individuals have a high prevalence of chronic conditions. This proposal builds on existing SNP regulations and is responsive to comments received in an RFI included in the CY 2027 MA and Part D proposed rule. CMS believes this proposal would help to ensure full-benefit duals in C-SNPs and certain I-SNPs have access to services that could support their activities of daily living, prevent future acute care events, and avoid any duplication of benefits across the two programs.


  • Amend the definition of a fully integrated dual eligible special needs plan (FIDE SNP) such that the contracts for the MA plan and the Medicaid managed care plan would no longer be required to be held by the same legal entity. This proposal removes an administrative barrier for a small number of highly integrated special needs plans that would otherwise be considered FIDE SNPs.


  • Expand the definition of a highly integrated dual eligible special needs plan (HIDE SNP) to recognize additional contractual affiliation models beyond common parent ownership where the MA organization offering the D-SNP assumes clinical and financial responsibility for both Medicare and Medicaid benefits. This proposed expansion would promote integrated care, increase beneficiary choice, and allow more flexible arrangements while preserving existing requirements regarding integration of Medicaid long-term services and supports or behavioral health coverage.


CMS is also including an RFI on whether to allow D-SNPs with an affiliated Medicaid managed care organization (integrated D-SNP) to also offer a coordination-only D-SNP for full-benefit and partial-benefit dually eligible individuals in the same service area as their integrated D-SNP. 


ADVaNCE MA Model

CMS is proposing a model that would test changes to quality incentives, allow targeting of certain supplemental benefits to low-income individuals, and shadow test a new CMMI Inferred Risk Adjustment Model. The mandatory, 10-year, ADVaNCE MA model would launch in 2029 in select states. CMS is also considering a future carveout of dialysis payment for End-Stage Renal Disease within the model.


“This model can help people with Medicare Advantage get more transparent, high-value care that meets their specific conditions and situation, including better prevention support and benefits,” said CMS Innovation Center Director Abe Sutton. 


“ADVaNCE MA, if finalized, is intended to level the playing field between regional health plans and large national carriers by allowing plans to tailor preventive supplemental benefits [food and produce, transportation for non-medical needs, and caregiver support] specifically to low-income subsidy enrollees,” CMS said.


“Through testing quality incentives by incrementally linking performance to payment, and inciting competition among plans at the state level, the model’s goal is to encourage innovation, enhance beneficiary choice and value. ADVaNCE MA will also shadow test a new risk adjustment model combing multiple methodologies to improve accuracy.” 


Components of the New Model

CMS said if finalized, the 10-year model test would begin in CY 2029, with a pre-implementation period starting on June 8, 2027, operating in randomly selected states with participation from a variety of plan types.


The components of the ADVaNCE MA model are:


  • CMMI Inferred Risk Adjustment Model: Explore, through shadow testing, an innovative risk adjustment methodology that builds upon the current CMS Hierarchical Condition Category (HCC) risk adjustment model by integrating multiple, existing data sources already available to CMS, including Original Medicare (OM) claims data, MA encounter data, and enrollment data. This shadow test would compile information on the usability of an alternative approach that could offer greater payment accuracy compared to the traditional risk adjustment methodology while not disrupting the MA market. The learnings from the shadow test are expected to inform future risk adjustment policy, CMS said.


  • The Diamond Ratings System: A redesigned quality program implemented in select states would replace the current MA and Part D Star Ratings and Quality Bonus Payment system with a localized, cohort-based, quality framework to incentivize continuous improvement and enable beneficiaries to make meaningful, geographically relevant plan comparisons in their local areas.


  • Targeted Supplemental Benefits for Low-Income Subsidy (LIS)-Eligible Individuals: New regulatory flexibilities would allow MA organizations to offer/target to Part D LIS-eligible individuals certain supplemental benefits, some of which are currently only available to chronically ill beneficiaries through Special Supplemental Benefits for the Chronically Ill. These supplemental benefits – healthy food and produce, transportation for non-medical needs, and supports for caregivers – have a focus on high-value prevention and serious illness support, with the goal of improving quality outcomes and reducing Medicare expenditures by avoiding and delaying costly, downstream care, CMS said. 


  • Dialysis Carveout for Beneficiaries with End-Stage Renal Disease: CMS said it is considering, but not currently proposing, to exclude payment for dialysis services from MA for beneficiaries with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) as a component of the ADVaNCE MA Model. Under this carveout, for beneficiaries with ESRD, dialysis would be covered by OM and paid through the ESRD Prospective Payment System (PPS), while the beneficiaries’ MA organizations would remain financially responsible for all other covered services. If proposed as a future component of the ADVaNCE MA model, details regarding interactions under the ESRD PPS would be included in future rulemaking, CMS said. 


Public Comment

CMS said it is issuing an accompanying RFI seeking input for future exploration to further expand primary care networks and utilize innovative technologies like AI.


The proposed rule will be open for public comment for 60 days following publication in the Federal Register here: https://www.federalregister.gov/d/2026-23960. 


For more information, view the fact sheet at: https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/contract-year-2028-policy-technical-changes-medicare-advantage-program-medicare-prescription-drug.

Comments or questions? Contact Patrick Connole at pconnole@parkplacelive.com.