Creator: Patrick Connole
Dept. of Labor Says it Cannot Verify Nursing Shortage

A proposed rule by the Dept. of Labor would alter large parts of the Permanent Labor Certification (PERM) program.
A proposed rule released on Nov. 17 by the Dept. of Labor would alter large parts of the Permanent Labor Certification (PERM) program, including the scrapping of Schedule A, which gives LTC employers who sponsor nurses and physical therapists for permanent residence in the U.S. a streamlined process to attain that status.
The proposal is titled, “Modernizing the Labor Market Test and Improving Protections for U.S. Workers in the PERM Immigrant Visa Program.” Find the draft rule at Federal Register :: Modernizing the Labor Market Test and Improving Protections for U.S. Workers in the PERM Immigrant Visa Program.
At issue is whether there is a labor shortage in the nursing sector, which allows for this easier path under Schedule A for immigrants to work in the country.
Verification of Shortage
The Dept. of Labor said it wants to make the change because it cannot verify the question of there being a national labor shortage with U.S. workers in short supply for various occupations, including nursing, listed in Schedule A.
“In the absence of a reliable, objective, and transparent methodology for updating Schedule A or the relevant substantive information needed to develop such a methodology, the department decided it could not add new occupations to Schedule A nor demonstrate that the occupations currently listed in Schedule A are still shortage occupations.”
The agency said it “is now proposing through this rulemaking to eliminate Schedule A.”
Background
In the background section of the proposed rule, the department said during the mid-1960s, in an effort to reduce administrative processing delays associated with the admission of aliens for permanent employment, the agency first established, by regulation, a mechanism for pre-certifying jobs for which U.S. workers were purportedly in short supply nationwide, which became known as Schedule A of the PERM labor certification program.
“Currently, Schedule A is set forth in the department's PERM labor certification regulations at 20 CFR 656.5 and enumerates a list of occupations for which the department predetermined that the statutory requirements have been met. The occupations currently listed in Schedule A are divided into two groups. Group I consists of physical therapists and professional nurses; Group II consists of aliens who possess exceptional ability in the sciences, arts, or performing arts,” the proposed rule said.
An employer seeking to hire an alien in an occupation listed in Schedule A is able to forego the labor market test for U.S. worker availability that is normally required for PERM labor certification.
The draft rule also said that the department has determined that the existence of Schedule A—both Group I and Group II—is incompatible with the plain language of the INA (Immigration and Nationality Act).
“Regarding Schedule A, generally, and Group I, specifically, the INA requires that before ‘any alien’ may be admitted into the United States to perform skilled or unskilled labor, the Secretary must certify that there are no qualified workers in the United States that are able and willing to perform the job. The INA does not exempt workers in a particular occupation from this requirement, nor does it provide the department with the authority to exempt any occupations from this requirement,” the draft said.
Comments or questions? Contact Patrick Connole at pconnole@parkplacelive.com.

